Coast FIRE Reddit: have you really hit your number?
- Coast FIRE Reddit: the top-ranked threads ask one question: will your investments be enough on their own for retirement, with no new contributions? FIRE stands for financial independence, retire early.
- The result depends mostly on the return you assume. For the same household, the Coast FIRE number goes from about $86,000 at 7% a year to about $291,000 at 3%.
- Example: at 33, you have $150,000 invested and $2,500 a month to cover starting at 65. To withdraw 4% a year, you need $750,000 at 65. At 5% a year, your $150,000 would grow to about $715,000: you're about $7,400 short today, or about $35,000 at 65. That's the gap the calculator shows.
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| What your savings need to cover | $4,500 in expenses minus $2,000 in Social Security | $2,500 a month |
| Over a year | $2,500 × 12 | $30,000 |
| Target savings at 65, 4% rule | $30,000 × 25 | $750,000 |
| Coast FIRE number at 33 | $750,000 ÷ 4.765 | about $157,400 |
| How much you're short | $157,400 minus your $150,000 | about $7,400 |
1. Coast FIRE Reddit: what are the threads asking?
Coast FIRE Reddit: the top-ranked threads mostly ask "Am I there yet?" Coast FIRE is the point where you can stop saving for retirement: the money you've already invested grows on its own and will be enough, along with your pension. Example: at 5% a year, $150,000 invested at 33 grows to about $715,000 at 65.
Among the threads Google ranks at the top are "How close to CoastFIRE am I?" on r/coastFIRE and "Am I at CoastFIRE?" on r/Bogleheads. For the big picture, read our guide to retiring early. For the step-by-step method, open the Coast FIRE calculator.
- Your money grows on its own thanks to compound interest: you earn interest on your savings and on the interest you've already earned. [1]
- Example: $1,000 invested at 5% a year grows to $1,050 after one year, then $1,102.50 after two years. [1]
- Your paycheck keeps covering your expenses until retirement. Only your retirement contributions become optional.
2. Coast FIRE: the return you assume changes everything
The assumed return almost single-handedly decides whether you're Coast FIRE. Keep the same hypothetical household: age 33, $150,000 invested, and $750,000 to reach at 65, 32 years from now.
Only the annual return changes in the table. At 5% a year, your money is multiplied by about 4.765 in 32 years. So your number is $750,000 ÷ 4.765, or about $157,400.
- At 7% a year, your $150,000 beats your number by about $64,000. You could stop saving for retirement.
- At 5% a year, you're about $7,400 short today, or about $35,000 at 65.
- At 3% a year, you're about $141,000 short today.
3. Real or nominal return: the mix-up that throws off the math
A calculation in today's dollars calls for a return after inflation. Inflation is the ongoing rise in prices, and the Consumer Price Index measures it. [4]
William Bengen, a financial planner, gives a worked example. Based on the historical data he cites, a portfolio with 60% stocks and 40% bonds could expect 8.2% a year, with 3% average inflation. Once inflation is taken out, that leaves almost 5.1% a year. [2]
- The math: 1.082 ÷ 1.03 = 1.0505, or about 5.05% real return.
- At 8.2% a year, your number at 33 would drop to about $60,000 (750,000 ÷ 12.45).
- At 5.05% a year, it goes back up to about $155,000. You thought you had 2.5 times your number, when you're actually still about $5,000 short.
4. The withdrawal rate: 25 times your expenses, or more?
The "× 25" figure comes from withdrawing 4% a year, since 100 ÷ 4 = 25. William Bengen tested that pace on U.S. retirements that started between 1926 and 1976, with 50% stocks and 50% Treasury bonds. [2]
A 4% initial withdrawal, then increased each year for inflation, never emptied the portfolio in less than 33 years. A withdrawal of 3% to 3.5% always lasted at least 50 years. [2]
- Another study points the same way. Published in 1998 in the journal of the AAII, the American Association of Individual Investors, it finds high success rates for inflation-adjusted withdrawals of 3% to 4%, mostly with stocks. [3]
- If your retirement could last more than 33 years, use a 3.5% withdrawal: you need $30,000 ÷ 0.035, or about $857,000 at 65.
- Your Coast FIRE number at 5% a year then goes from about $157,000 to about $180,000.
5. Social Security: what amount should you put in your math?
In your math, use your estimated Social Security benefit at the age you plan to claim it. Your my Social Security account, on the agency's website, gives you an estimate of your future benefits. [5]
- Starting at 62, you can claim your retirement benefit. [5] [6] If you were born on or after January 2, 1960, your full retirement age is 67. [7]
- Before 67, the amount goes down by 5/9 of 1% a month for the first 36 months, then by 5/12 of 1% a month beyond that. [8]
- Example: 24 months × 5/9% = a 13.3% reduction. An estimate of $2,300 at 67 becomes about $1,993 at 65.
- A lower salary can reduce your estimate. The calculation uses your highest-paid years, and years with no income can count if you don't have enough working years. [9]
6. After your Coast FIRE number: slow down without losing anything
Hitting your number doesn't mean you stop working. You can slow down, for example by taking a lower-paying job, as long as that salary covers your expenses.
- Keep a cushion. In the example, aiming for $180,000 instead of $157,000 also covers a 3.5% annual withdrawal.
- Your own contributions stay yours. In a 401(k), the retirement account offered by your employer, the money you put in always belongs to you. [11]
- Your employer's share can be lost if you change jobs. It can depend on how long you've worked there, for example 100% after 3 years. If you leave earlier, the unvested part can be lost. [11]
- Plan for health insurance. If you lose coverage through your job before 65, you can buy a plan on the official Marketplace. The help you get depends on your income and household size. [10]
Your questions
Do real estate and your company's stock count toward Coast FIRE?
That's the "How close to CoastFIRE am I?" thread on r/coastFIRE: the author holds mortgaged real estate and employer stock they can't sell yet. The top comment (15 points) says they're well past Coast FIRE. Another (6 points) counts only money that's invested and easy to sell: for $100,000 in expenses a year, you need 100,000 × 25 = $2,500,000. [2] How to check: add up only what you could sell to pay for your retirement, then compare that total with your number.
$560,000 at 48: is that enough to be Coast FIRE?
On r/Bogleheads, in "Am I at CoastFIRE?", a 48-year-old man asks whether the $560,000 in his 401(k) is enough. The top comment points him to r/coastFIRE. The next one (12 points) says there's no way to know without knowing his future needs, and that his debts other than a mortgage work against him. Example: at 5% a year, $560,000 grows to about $1,284,000 at 65 (× 2.292 in 17 years). A 4% withdrawal then pays about $51,300 a year: compare that figure with your expenses minus your Social Security. [2]
Should you take a much lower-paying job once you're Coast FIRE?
In "Feedback on Potential Coast FIRE" on r/financialindependence, a tech worker wants to switch to $50,000 a year. The top comment (60 points) suggests a quiet but better-paid role instead: a low salary isn't always less stressful. Another (15 points) suggests keeping your job and doing less. How to check: make sure the new salary covers your expenses. In this thread, $50,000 against $73,000 in expenses leaves $23,000 a year that their spouse's $68,000 salary will have to cover. A similar question, finding a less demanding but well-paid job, comes up in "Next steps after reaching the cusp of CoastFIRE" on r/coastFIRE and "Too Rich to Care, Not Rich Enough to Quit" on r/Fire.
At 33 with $1.2 million, can you slow down your saving?
The post in "Can i slow down saving in 2 years, 33yo" on r/coastFIRE was deleted, but its comments remain. The top one (17 points) says yes: you can spend more and stop worrying. The next one (15 points) points out that the author has $1.2 million and earns $300,000 a year. Example: at 5% a year, $1,200,000 invested at 33 grows to about $5,718,000 at 65 (× 4.765). A 4% withdrawal would then pay about $229,000 a year. [2]
A million dollars in your early thirties: is that too much to live on $60,000 a year?
In "Next steps after reaching the cusp of CoastFIRE" on r/coastFIRE, the author passed a million in net worth in their early thirties and aims for about $60,000 a year. The top comment (2 points) calls that much money excessive for retiring at 60. The math backs it up: you need 60,000 × 25 = $1,500,000 at 60. [2] Example: at 33 and 5% a year, money is multiplied by 3.73 in 27 years. So the number is about $402,000: a million is 2.5 times that.
Should you count your pension and Social Security toward Coast FIRE?
The author of "FP Indicates We Have Reached CoastFIRE but it is highly dependent on several factors" on r/coastFIRE wonders whether only savings count. The top comment (3 points) says you can count that income, since you'll receive it. It adds one condition: your pension must still hold if you go part-time or leave before the required number of years. Example: in the calculator's household, $2,000 a month in Social Security lowers the goal by 2,000 × 12 × 25 = $600,000. [2]
Should you plan for buying a house in your Coast FIRE math?
The post in "[22M] CoastFIRE Plan Check" on r/coastFIRE was deleted. In a comment, the author plans a $50,000 to $70,000 down payment. The top comment (17 points) only praises how far ahead they are. Another (2 points) warns that the price of a future home will weigh heavily on their numbers. Example: at 5% a year, $60,000 invested at 22 grows to about $489,000 at 65 (× 8.15 in 43 years). Taking that money out for a down payment takes about $489,000 away from your retirement: redo your number before you buy.
You've hit your number: keep saving, slow down, or spend more?
That's the question in "Coast F.I.R.E Achieved. What now? 33yo" on r/coastFIRE. The replies in the thread aren't covered here. Spending more today doesn't change your number, as long as your retirement expenses stay the same. If that lifestyle follows you into retirement, every extra $500 a month adds 500 × 12 × 25 = $150,000 to your goal. [2] Example: at 33 and 5% a year, your number then goes up by about $31,500 (150,000 ÷ 4.765).
How do you get to your money before 59½?
On r/Bogleheads, the author of "Best investment approach for retiring under 55?" worries about locking up 25% of their income in retirement accounts, a 401(k) and an IRA (individual retirement account). The replies aren't covered here. The rule comes from the IRS, the U.S. tax agency. Before 59½, a withdrawal from an employer plan, like a 401(k), can cost an additional 10% tax. [13] Example: withdrawing $10,000 then costs $1,000 more. If you leave your employer at 55 or later, money in that employer's plan avoids this tax. This exception doesn't apply to an IRA. [13]
Should you keep bonds during the coast phase?
In "Another bonds post" on r/Bogleheads, a 41-year-old investor who will be Coast FIRE next year asks why they should keep their 15% in bonds. The replies aren't covered here. FINRA, the organization that oversees U.S. brokers, explains that bonds generally move less than stocks and help diversify. [12] Their price generally falls when interest rates rise. [12] Example: with 15% in bonds, if stocks lose 30% and bonds don't move, your portfolio loses 25.5% instead of 30%.
A market drop puts you back below your number: what should you do?
In "Investments have gone from $1.3M to $1M because of tariffs" on r/coastFIRE, the author thought they were Coast FIRE before the drop. The replies aren't covered here. Redo the math with the new value. Example: in the calculator's household, $150,000 that loses 20% falls to $120,000, below the $157,400 number. To get back to the number at 38, about $200,900, you need to put in about $8,600 a year for 5 years, at 5% a year.
Laid off before 65: how do you keep health insurance?
In "Laid off, kinda bummed out." on r/Fire, the author finds out what health insurance costs without their employer's share. The replies aren't covered here. Losing your employer's coverage can open a Special Enrollment Period on the official Marketplace. [14] With COBRA, the federal law that extends your coverage for a while, you pay the full premium, including the employer's share, plus a small fee. [15] How to check: compare that price with the Marketplace offer, where the help you get depends on your income and household size. [15]
- Your financial plan, 100% free, in 2 minutes.
- Your pension, savings, and investments on one chart.
- The age when you can stop saving, recalculated with every change.
Sources
- How does compound interest work? · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau · October 19, 2023
- Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data · William P. Bengen, Journal of Financial Planning · October 1994
- Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate That Is Sustainable · AAII Journal · February 1998
- Consumer Price Index Frequently Asked Questions · U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics · September 25, 2025
- Retirement · USAGov · July 30, 2026
- 20 CFR 404.310, When am I entitled to old-age benefits? · U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo)
- 20 CFR 404.409, What is full retirement age? · U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo)
- 20 CFR 404.410, How does SSA reduce my benefits when my entitlement begins before full retirement age? · U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo)
- 20 CFR 404.211, Computing your average indexed monthly earnings. · U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo)
- Health coverage for retirees · HealthCare.gov
- Retirement topics - Vesting · Internal Revenue Service · April 8, 2026
- Bonds · FINRA
- Topic no. 558, Additional tax on early distributions from retirement plans other than IRAs · Internal Revenue Service · November 9, 2026
- Special enrollment opportunities · HealthCare.gov
- Unemployed people · HealthCare.gov
Reviewed by Valentin Orru, Growth Expert in Fintech and AI
This article is for education only. It is not investment advice: investing carries a risk of loss.